Every week on The Mosaic we end with an original song and its cover. Vote for your favorite at firstname.lastname@example.org!
Results for Last Week:
Kate Bush is the resounding victor of last week’s battle with Greg Laswell. I was surprised by this outcome because, honestly, Bush’s version sounds a little shrill, but after researching “This Woman’s Work” I realized that this really works for the lyrical content. Bush wrote the song “This Woman’s Work” to accompany a scene from the movie She’s Having A Baby in which the lives of a woman and her unborn child are endangered. Singing with a tremulous voice at certain points and breaking into a full-throated cry at others, Bush has much more of an emotional presence than Laswell who spends most of the song singing barely above a whisper.
This Week: Bon Iver vs. Deadwood Floats
The song this week is “Holocene,” written by the frontman of Bon Iver Justin Vernon. Vernon says the song “is a metaphor for when you’re not doing well. But it’s also a song about redemption and realizing that you’re worth something; that you’re special and not special at the same time.” (songfacts) Since its release, the song was ranked by the Rolling Stone as the 22nd best single of 2011, won 2nd place at Stereogum’s Gummy Awards, and was nominated for Song of the Year at the 54th Grammy Awards.
Now that you have sufficient evidence of the song’s awesomeness, we can go about deciding who did it better. You guys know about Bon Iver, the band who has it all in the world of indie folk. They won the 2012 Grammy Award for Best New Artist as well as the Grammy Award for Best Alternative Music Album, an album which they just so happened to record in their months living in a middle-of-nowhere cabin. Their challengers hail from the sleepy old town a few miles down the road of Columbus, Ohio. Deadwood Floats began in 2009 almost as a hobby to distract them from their day jobs. Today, the band is made up of six members and recording music like “Holocene” which I think you’ll find to be quite accomplished in its own right.
Contains explicit language.